Mystery discount

Nissan Rogue vs. Mazda CX-5 - Comox Valley, South of Campbell River


Nissan Rogue vs. Mazda CX-5: Which Is Better? - Comox Valley on Vancouver Island

by Doug DeMuro

The compact-crossover segment seems to be getting more competitive by the day, with new challengers constantly joining and new technology constantly being added. Two of our favorite entrants in the segment are the Nissan Rogue and the Mazda CX-5, both of which -- in keeping with the rest of the segment -- offer new designs and lots of technology. But which is better? And which one should you buy? We've created an in-depth comparison to answer exactly that, but first let's see what's new with both crossovers.

Nissan Rogue

Following a full redesign last year, the Rogue is unchanged for the 2015 model year.

Mazda CX-5

The CX-5 is largely unchanged for 2015 save for newly standard keyless entry and ignition on Touring and Grand Touring models.


According to automotive experts at J.D. Power, the Rogue offers better-than-average reliability. Unfortunately, the firm has not yet rated the latest Mazda CX-5. But Consumer Reports has rated both crossovers for reliability, and it says that both the CX-5 and the Rogue have earned above-average scores, with the CX-5 scoring slightly higher than the Rogue.

As for warranty length, these two crossovers are identical: Both tout 3 years or 36,000 miles of bumper-to-bumper protection and 5 years or 60,000 miles of powertrain coverage. Due to similarities in warranty length and reliability scores, we can't say that either of these beats out the other in terms of dependability, but we think that car shoppers will be happy with either model.

Fuel Economy

The CX-5 offers two powertrains. Base models use a 155-horsepower 2.0-liter 4-cylinder that's mated to either a 6-speed manual or a 6-speed automatic transmission. The 6-speed manual gets the best fuel economy ratings -- 26 miles per gallon in the city and 35 mpg on the highway -- though drivers who choose the automatic will still see an impressive 26 mpg city/32 mpg hwy.

Shoppers who want more power can opt for a 2.5-liter 4-cylinder engine, which makes 184 hp and 185 lb-ft of torque. Only offered with an automatic, that powertrain returns an excellent 25 mpg city/32 mpg hwy

Meanwhile, the Rogue has only one powertrain: a 170-hp 2.5-liter 4-cylinder, which is mated solely to a fuel-saving continuously variable transmission. The Rogue's fuel economy figures are also stellar, coming in at 26 mpg city/33 mpg hwy.

Although there are slight fuel economy differences here and there between the CX-5 and the Rogue, we'd say that these two crossovers are roughly even, and we think most shoppers will be impressed with either one.


In the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's crash testing, the CX-5 earned a perfect 5-star overall score, topping the Rogue's 4-star rating. The CX-5 also beat out the Rogue in testing carried out by the nonprofit Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, earning a Top Safety Pick+ rating to the Rogue's also-excellent Top Safety Pick score.

When it comes to safety features, both the Rogue and the CX-5 have a lot of benefits. Both crossovers offer all the usual stuff such as anti-lock brakes, traction control and side-curtain airbags. But from there, there are a few differences. Only the Rogue comes standard with a backup camera, for instance, and only the CX-5 has an automatic braking feature built in to its forward-collision warning system. Only the Rogue offers a 360-degree top-down camera, which can be tremendously helpful in tight spaces, and only the CX-5 offers automatic wipers.

So which one is better? We'd say the CX-5 just beats out the Rogue when it comes to safety, both in terms of crashworthiness and equipment. Yes, we like the Rogue's 360-degree camera, but not as much as we like the CX-5's available automatic braking system.


In terms of technology, we think the CX-5 offers a few slight benefits over the Rogue. For instance, only the CX-5 offers a remote-start feature. Only the CX-5 touts automatic wipers and an automatic braking system. Only the CX-5 offers adaptive headlights or xenon headlights, and only the CX-5 offers auto-dimming mirrors.

Admittedly, the Rogue has a few unique features of its own, such as the aforementioned 360-degree camera and a backup camera that's standard rather than optional. We also think both crossovers offer roughly the same infotainment capabilities. But for true technophiles, we think the CX-5 has a slight edge over its Rogue rival.


If you compare starting prices between the Rogue and the CX-5, you'll see that the Mazda is much cheaper than its Nissan rival, but that's a little deceptive: A base-level CX-5 comes standard with the crossover's smaller engine and a manual transmission. Upgrade to the 2.5-liter engine and an automatic, and you'll actually pay more than you would for a base-level Rogue.

Is the CX-5 worth the slight price premium? We're not so sure. Both crossovers offer roughly the same level of standard equipment, though the Rogue touts a standard backup camera. The Rogue offers more room than the CX-5, and only the Rogue boasts an available third-row seat, which can be an important feature for some shoppers. We think the value category is a toss-up, but if we had to pick a winner, it might be the Rogue.

Autotrader's Advice

The Mazda CX-5 and the Nissan Rogue are two of today's best compact crossovers -- and it shows. Both SUVs offer stellar fuel economy, lots of technology, competitive pricing and a lot of safety equipment. Picking a winner here is hard, but we'll go with the Mazda. It offers a better safety record, slightly better gas mileage, more technology and a more involved driving experience. Still, we like the Rogue a lot, and we wouldn't fault anyone for purchasing one.


Visit our website for many more details and pictures at

We are a family-run, locally owned and operated dealership in the Comox Valley on Vancouver Island specializing in new and used vehicle sales, and servicing all areas of the Comox Valley including Courtenay, Comox, Campbell River, Parksville, Nanaimo, Victoria and all of Vancouver Island.  Call us toll-free at 1-877-458-2110.

Come visit Vancouver Island's Premier pre-owned vehicle location across from Costco and Crown Isle in Courtenay, BC. We have an exceptionally large and fully reconditioned inventory with a complete 155-point inspection on every vehicle! Hundreds more on-line to choose from. We also service all makes and models with 6 service bays, including Toyota, Nissan, Honda, Ford, Dodge, Chevrolet, Chrysler, Hyundai, Jeep, Pontiac, Subaru, Kia, VW, BMW, Mercedes and so many more. Tour our welcoming facility, meet our staff and join us for a coffee!

We are the one of the busiest pre-owned vehicle dealerships on Vancouver Island. Along with our fine line of New Mazda cars and Used Mazda vehicles, we market pre-owned import and domestic brands of quality Cars, Trucks, Vans, CUV’s and SUV’s - you name it and we will find it - and can help you get into the car or truck you need, no matter your current credit situation, without hassle or delay. Let us help you!

For more than 20 years, Courtenay Mazda has been a trusted and respected used car dealer in the Comox Valley on Vancouver Island. We are dedicated to ensuring that you go far in a used car or truck, and it starts with an exclusive inventory of quality, reliable used cars and trucks, and a financing service that can provide you with guaranteed approval, help you restore your credit, and get you the best rate possible for your needs and situation.

Courtenay Mazda – MVSA Certified #40158